From brusil@snad.ncsl.nist.gov Sun Oct 30 03:25:00 1994 Return-Path: Date: Sun, 30 Oct 94 03:21:07 EST From: Dr. Paul J. Brusil - Consultant Message-Id: <9410300821.AA06116@snad.ncsl.nist.gov> To: bmurrill@attmail.com, dsm@nemo.ncsl.nist.gov, jlw@hpcnd.cnd.hp.com, nmsig@nemo.ncsl.nist.gov Subject: NMSIG-94/362 Sept Meeting Report Cc: aow-nmsig@stc.ipa.go.jp, ewos-egnm@external.iihe.ac.be, snmsigl@nemo.ncsl.nist.gov NMSIG-94/362 SUMMARY REPORT OF SEPTEMBER 1994 OIW NMSIG Attendance: 27 aggregate (7 - 20, per session) Inputs : 151 (see attached list) Outputs: 1 change to Working Agreements, 1 deletion from Working Agreements, 14 Liaisons (see attached list), 2 reports (see attached list) Next Meetins: OIW SNMSIG, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD 12 Dec - 15 Dec 94 Email Managemnt, NIST, Gaithersburg, MD 12 Dec - 14 Dec 94 Distributed Systems Management, NIS, Gaithersburg, MD 13 Dec - 14 Dec 94 Security SIG, NIST, Gaithersburg, M 13 Dec 94 ACTIVITIES/ACCOMPLISHMENTS AT SEPTEMBER MEETING Charter and SIG Name Change - In recognition of on-going and future work beyond the scope of managing just network technologies and OSI technologies, and in recognition that management technlogies of interest to the group are applicable to managing various information technology sysems, and in recognition that management technologies other than just OSI management are of interest to the Group, the name of the NMSIG was changed to the Systems and Network Management SG (SNMSIG). A revised charter with attendant work plan summaries was accepted (NMSIG-94/350) and will be incorporated into Part 1, section 4.8.8 of the OIW Working Agreements. The new name and charter were liaised (NMSIG-94/374) to all relevant partner and otherwise related organizations. This charter change formally sanctions support of the SNMSIG to other related OIW activities such as those associated with the Email Management Working Group, the Distributed Systems Management Workng Group, and the Performance Management Working Group. ISO/RWS-CC Liaions - Because of recent industry concern about industry (re-)use of compilable versions of GDMO derived from standards (such as ISO/IEC 10164-x, ISO/IEC 10165-x, and ITU-T G.744) being potentially perceived to be copy right violations of ISO/IEC and ITU-T publications, and therefore because of the purported stoppage by some vendors from implementing products which include managed objects with such DMO, a liaison (NMSIG-94/351) was generated requesting the Regional Workshop Coordinating Committee to send a formal request to ISO/IEC and ITU-T to waive copy right on GDMO in all standards with embedded GDMO. - In order to maintain a timely flow of OSI management standards and other documents into the SNMSIG, a liaison (NMSIG-94/352) was generated requesting that C. Michael Chernick be designated as the liaison officer between ISO/IEC SC21/WG4 and the OIW SNMSIG. Security Management - Security and security management topics were discussed in joint session of the SECSIG and NMSIG - It was reported that the SECSIG would continue considering what work it might undertake with respect to the Security Association Management Protcol (SAMP) which may have value in managing certain aspects of the security services for OSI system management communications. It was agreed that there would be another joint SECSIG/SNMSIG meeting in December 1994 at which the SAMP topic would be reviewed as well as other potential topics associated with managing security services. - It was reported that the SECSIG would be involved with the development of a security integrity transforation pDISP. Accordingly, it was felt that this pDISP work should also be considered at the joint meeting in December; and, that any alignment of, and/or errata to the OIW Stable Agreements on, GULS (and/or management use of GULS agreements) relative to the security integrity transformation pDISP should also be considered. - It was agreed that the SECSIG would begin development of security confidentiality working agreements based on the GULS base standard; and, that accordingly the SNMSIG would, in parallel, develop woking agreements on the management use of these new security confidentiality agreements. Review of these topics would also occur at the December joint meeting. - In recognition of new security/security management efforts in ANSI T1M1 (NMSIG-94/340), it was decided that attempts should be made to re-establish a liaison relationship between the NMSIG and T1M1. It was agreed that by the time of the next T1M1 meeting in mid Novembr 1994, a liaison (NMSIG- 94/360) would be conveyed indicating that it is felt that (a) security management pDISPs currently under joint development by the RWs would meet certain T1M1 requrements, (b) OIW Stable Agreements on GULS (IS0 11586, Generic Upper Layer Security) would met certain other T1M1 requirements, (c) yet other of the T1M1 requirements might drive new RW profiling activities, such as the development of new OIW agreements on a GULS-based confidentiality service and the RW's development of new security/security management profiles, and (d) because of these various relationships, re-invigoration of a differently-foused, yet non-the-less symbiotic, liaison between T1M1 and the NMSIG/SECSIG would be useful. Mr. Hal Folts believed that he could act as a liaison officer - Subsequent to the OIW Meeting, it was ascertained that Mr. Lee LaBarre had received support to accept the Regional Workshop editorship of the profile(s) associated with the Objects and Attributes for Access Control standard (ISO/IEC IS 10164-9. The time duration and international travel available through his support is limited. A workplan and potentially a first WD pDISP are expected to be available by the time of the December 1994 OIW meetings. Conformance - Joseph Ghetie, OIW point of contact for PT27 (CMIP ISP conformance), gave a status report of the work of PT27 and of the OIW contributions to PT27. Having now expanded and harmonized the CTS3-NM inputs to PT27 to include an ISP 11183-orientation with several Abstract Test Suites (ATSs) and test cases, it is felt that the PT27 outputs now reflect good work that should be fast tracked to standardize CMIP Profile Test Suites (PTSs). Accordingly, a liaison (NMSIG- 94/353) was generated that (a) endorsed the stability and comprehensiveness of the CMIP Test Suite Structure and Test Management Protocol (TSS&TP), the CMIP ATS/PTS, and Upper Layer Test Management Protocol Interfaces, (b) endorsed submission of the CMIP PTS to ISO SGFS, (c) endorsed the position to skip ROSE ATS work which would address applications-independent test cases (for ROSE and for CMI), and (d) appointed J. Ghetie as the OIW representative to the final PT27 approval meeting in Ictiber 1994. - P. Brusil announced that the EWOS Project Team 28 focused on managed object (MO) conformance testing was commencing and that he would act as the OIW coordinator and point-of- contact. It is expected that a small group of SNMSIG members will be rcruited to support OIW contributions to PT28. It was also noted that there were several other efforts underway that may have relevance to the PT28 focus area. These other areas include (a) the PREPARE project in Europe that apparently includes aspects of MO interoperability testing, (b) the PROST project in the U.K. that apparently has as one of its goals the validation of the CTS3-NM MO conformance testing methodology that was delivered to PT27, and (c) the Electronic Communication Implementation Forum (ECIF), formerly the Electronic Bonding Forum, that purportedly includes within its aegise end-to-end management testing. The exact nature of these three activities will be investigated and, as appropriate, relevant feedback will be forwarded to PT28. - P. Kerr, from the Defense Information Systems Agency's (DISA's) Joint Interoperability Test Center (JITC), announced the potential U.S. government development of formal test methodologies, ATSs, and so on for Intenet Protocol Suite (IPS) management technologies. It was pointed out that some of the difficuly associated with such work is that because of ambiguities in IPS management specifications, such as SNMPv1, there are undocumented community resolutions of ambiguities. It was felt that the SNMSIG would want to keep abreast of any further activities that might be pursued by DISA/JITC and/or others. CULR - The SNMSIG referred to the OIW Upper Layer SIG, the AOW NMSIG input (NMSIG-94/320) relative to the CULR ISP -11188. Because of the CULR ballot cycle, it was suggested by the OIW ULSIG that this input should be formally brought forward as National Body comments during the CULR balloting process. Enterprise Systems Management - A. Tang reported (NMSIG-94/345) on progress in developing ensembles oriented for the Enterprise Management of electronic mail and networks. It was noted that a targeted user of such ensembles would be the CDPD cellular telecommunications industry wherein (a) Email Management ensembles would be useful for managing CDPD's X.400 service used for CDPD billing, and (b) the Lower Layers Ensembles would be used in managing CDPD's CLNP. - A. Tang reported (NMSIG-94/345) on progress in developing frameworks for Enterprise Network Management (NMSIG-94/343) and Enterprise Email Management (NMSIG-94/342). These frameworks are deemded necessary prior to developing ensembles pertinent to each area, such as the Network Status Monitoring Ensemble (NMSIG-94/277) and the Email Systems Monitoring Ensemble (NMSIG-94/344), respectively. Upon discussion, it was felt that a goal should be to determine if it is possible to create just one framework; and, to refine the network status monitoring and mail management frameworks from it. It is noted that other ensembles, such as the INTAP LAN Fault Management ensemble, are not apparently based on some guiding framework; and, that the notion of a framework would be useful. - A.Tang introduced the Network Status Monitoring, Net Stat Mon, Ensemble (NMSIG-94/277). The purpose of this ensemble is to achieve integrated LAN management, not to replace SNMP MIBs. This ensemble differs from the INTAP LAN Fault Management ensemble (NMSIG-94/230R) in that the Net Stat Mon ensemble (a) uses different domain concepts and includes and builds upon the concept of recursive subdomains, and (b) expands the monitoring capabilities to include performance monitoring. The plan is to incorporate FDDI monitoring shortly; and, to review the work in detail before, or during, the December 1994 OIW. - A discussion was initiated, and will be continued electronically, regarding what would be the best method(s) for deriving GDMO-based management information (e.g., for the Net Stat Mon Ensemble) when such GDMO-based management information is related to management information that is also defined in extant SNMP-based MIBs. The method currently used in developing the GDMO for the Net Stat Mon ensemble apparently is a form of abstract translation of, e.g., the IPS RMON MIB. There are, however, arguments that favor the IIMC approach for deriving GDMO from the extant IPS RMON MIB. - A. Tang reported on plans to develop other ensembles oriented toward Enterprise Management. These include (a) a Back-Up Ensemble, and (b) a Load Sharing Management Ensemble. The former will build upon the ISO/IEC 10164-19 draft pertinent to domains as well as upon X/Open Systems Management work on Back-Up to provide management restoration transparency. The latter is focused on collaborative management computing (a.k.a. management bandwidth transparency) and could be used, e.g., to coordinate hand- over of management responsibilities between different management centers. - H.Folts and E.Zeisler presented the first results of their work toward developing a framework for ensembles (NMSIG- 94/335). The reaction was mixed with some indicating support and others indicating that the work was obscure and that it was not obvious how it could be used. There was discussion as to some of the additions that might b useful to its companion (lower layer) network model in order for the model to be applicable o ensembles oriented for upper layer and systems/applications management. It was also deemed appropriate that this framework be harmonized with those being progressed by A.Tang for Enterprise Network Management and Enterprise Email Management. It was understood that at least some of the NMSIG comments would be folded in to the work before it was presented at the NMF General Meeting in October 1994. The OIW NMSIG offered to provide further comments/inputs as the work evolves. Email Management - The Email Management Group's meeting, scheduled for late September 1994, was canceled. The group intends to progress sme of its work, such as the Enterprise Email Management Framework (NMSIG-94/342) and the two email management ensembles (NMSIG-94/341 and /344), via electronic discussions. These documents were introduced by A. Tang at the Sept. 1994 OIW. At the Sept OIW it was noted that the email message tracking/tracing ensemble is not oriented to management of resources; rather, it provides a kind of fault management capability for email messages. - The Email Management Group, while being focused in the interim on eforts within the Electronic Mail Association (EMA), intends to meet, both independently and jointly with the NMSIG, at the Dec 1994 OIW. Management Coexistence - M. Chernick introduced the X/Open and NMF Joint Interdomain Management (JIDM) documents (MSIG-94/084, /244-246) related to matters of coexistence of ISO systems management technology, Internet management technology, OMG management technology and ISO Open Distributed Processing technology. X/Open and the NMF had made these documents available to the NMSI with the caveat that these documents are for limited distribution to only those personnel willing to critique the documents. One reviewer had been identified by the call for participation issued after during the summer. There was some additional interest evident at the Sept 1994 OIW NMSIG meeting; and , it was furthermore hypothesized that members of the Distributed Systems Management Working Group would be seriously interested in the topics and in contributing to OIW review efforts on these documents. Accordingly, a liaison (NMSIG-94/339) was created conveying (a) OIW's observation that JIDM specifications will fill a critical gap and support the interworking of object-oriented technology (CORBA) and management technologies (OSI, IPS), (b) comments regarding transaction concurrency, (c) the OIW SNMSIG's plan to seek an expansion of the OIW constituency supporting OIW review of the JIDM specifications, and (d) the SNMSIG's desire to continue OIW/JIDM collaboration in this area. - M. Chernick reported little support was generated from the community relative to his June 1994 electronic call for participation in efforts to translate the IETF Frame Relay MIB (RFC 1604) and the IETF AToM SONET MIB (RFC 1595) into GDMO equivalents. One potential contributor had reported difficulties in translating the IETF Frame Relay MIB into the proper SNMP version for input into an IIMC MIB-to-GDMO converter. Community problems regarding multiple, parallel, autonomously-defined definitions for SONET/SDH were introduced (NMSIG-94/300). Accordingly, L. LaBarre volunteered to provide a translation of the RFC 1595 into GDMO and an associated ASN.1 module so that it could become possible to begin identifying the magnitude of the discrepancies between the ITU-T G.774 SDH MIB and the purportedly similar IETF SONET MIB (RFC 1595). - There was some discussion and interest expressed about management sub-agent technology. It was felt that at least a more detailed description of the problem to be addressed by such technology was needed before determining if there should be any particular role that the OIW SNMSIG should play relative to the architecting, modeling, standardization, and/or profiling of such technology. Performance Management - M.Chernick introduced the most current WD pDISPs (NMSIG- 94/269, /285, /296, 363, /364) and RW comments on the Performance Management profiles. It was reported that very little interest in supporting the completion of these documents had come forward from an electronic call for participation. Furthermore, since NMSIG-9/363-364 had just recently been received out of the Sept AOW NMSIG meeting, it was felt that i would not be possible to conduct an adequate review during the time allocated to this subject at the Sept 1994 OIW NMSIG. Subsequent to the Sept 1994 OIW, a liaison (NMSIG-94/367) was generated conveying the OIW SNMSIG's concurrence on endorsing the performance management profiles as being harmonized as pDISPs ready for ISO SGFS submission. - There was interest expressed from the Lower Layers Ensemble effort in having RW resources progressing an AOM251x General Performance Management Profile. Such a request was incorporated into liaison NMSIG-94/67. - OIW NMSIG agenda work items associated with the Performance Management Working Group (PMG) were postponed until the December 1994 OIW. At that time it is expected that the PMWG specfications will be stabilized in X/Open; and, that OIW SNMSIG efforts can commence to develop a workplan/schedule and to begin to outline corresponding OIW working agreements. Lower Layer MO Profiles and Ensembles - A review of all RW inputs pertinent to this area was conducted by Kedem Kaminsky and several liaisons were created a a result of the discussions. - Substantial and mixed discussions took place regarding the taonomy for lower layer MO profiles. From the lower layer experts view point, it was felt that updating each T and R ISP with an optional management capability was acceptable, and that use of FOM profiles for lower layer MOs was not acceptable. (Ensembles would then provide the mechanism for selecting among the optional ISP management capabilities.) Others argued that such an approach would be time-consuming and prevent early, wide-spread availability of any Lower Layer MO profiles. There was no input from Upper Layer experts regarding appropriate taxonomy and profiling for upper layer MOs. Similarly, there was no discussion regarding profiling of MOs for non-OSI or hybrid (e.g., management proxy) resources/services. Accordingly, a liaison (NMSIG- 94/357) was created indicating tha at least for the situation for lower layer MO taxonomy and MO profiling, the desirable approach is to update each T and R ISP. This liaison also conveys OIW's concurrence that ensembles should be identified under an AOM3x taxonomy branch. - AOW NMSIG comments (AOW NM N866) were reviewed and a liaison (NMSIG-94/355) was created acknowledging OIW agreement with many points and requesting AOW clarifications on a few points. Similarly, other AOW NMSIG comments (AOW NM N905R) were reviewed and a liaison (NMSIG-94/356) was created acknowleding agreement with some points, requesting clarification of one point, and indicating the plan on how lower layer ensembles could address manager role conformance requirements. - EWOS EGNM comments (EGNM/94/211) were reviewed and a liaison (NMSIG-94/337) was created acknowleding OIW agreement with most points and a disagreement regarding how to address MOCS static vs dynamic conditins. - A liaison was created (NMSIG-94/354) (a) indicating that revision 8 of the Connectionles Network Systems Management Ensemble (CLNSME) is now available for RW review, (b) summarizing changes between revisions 7 and 8, (c) proposing a progression schedule that maintained consistency of RW reviews upon the same revision of CLNSME, and (d) proposing that pDISP harmonization be targeted for completion during early 1995. - A liaison (NMSIG-94/358) is to be created alerting the RWs to the availability for comment/review of lower layer MO profiles on the OIW informatin server. Management Guidelines - S.Riegner introduced the Ensemble Guidelines topic indicating that there was substantial confusion surrounding the status of the document and AOW and OIW comments against it. It was not clear as to which version (EWOS EGNM/94/203 or some future, not yet seen version) of the Guidelines is to be reviewed and approved. Furthermore, it was observed that previous OIW comments that had been agreed by EWOS (EGNM/94/205) did not appear to be in EGNM/94/203. In light that some of the OIW comments were non-trivial, it was felt that an OIW endorsement culd not be given at the Sept 1994 OIW, and that it would be best to seek clarification from the document editor as to (a) what is the status of the comment resolutions, and (b) which version of the document is to be endorsed as harmonized. While it was hoped that such clarification could be obtained and an OIW NMSIG electronic assessment/approval of the document could be obtained in time for the EWOS EGNM meeting and/or the RWS-CC, unfortunately, this was not able to be accomplished within the time available. - Regarding the Guidelines for Managed Object Profiling, no further comments were made. With the OIW endorsement having been made at the June 1994 OIW, the work on this Guideline was considered complete and was awaiting final approval by the October 1994 RWS-CC. - Regarding the Guidelines for MO Taxonomy (NMSIG-94/302 [AOW NM N784]), a liaison was created (NMSIG-94/359) conveying (a) the major comment (discussed in detail in liaison NMSIG-94/357) regarding the use of FOM ISPs for MO profiles, and (b) numerous editorial and minor concerns that were brought to the attention of the OIW NMSIG. Distributed Systems Management (DSM) - The DSMWG met independently, as well as jointly with the NMSIG. The DSMWG secretary's report is provided in NMSIG- 94/369. There were presentations covering a variety of topics including OSF, DSM, Integrated Enterprise Management, NMF/SPIRIT, X/OPEN - Other topics considered included the development of a document that collates, aggregates, filters, and synthesizes distributed systems management requirements from several extant requirements documents from larger users (e.g., DoD) and/or user groups (e.g., POSIX, OMNIPoint). Subsequent to the Sept 1994 OIW, an announcement was made on the DSM email exploder that the first draft was available by FTP from the NIST infoserver nemo.ncsl.nist.gov. - Subsequent to the Sept OIW, it was announced that the nmsig email exploder was deleted as a subscriber to the DSM email exploder. Accordingly, individuals from the NMSIG email exploder who wish to join the DSM email exploder will need to send a request to and in the message put: subscribe dsm MISCELLANEOUS - Because of the sustained lack of an editor or any volnteers with interests in the Service Request Management Ensemble, the draft of this ensemble was deleted from Part 18, Annex D.4, of the OIW Working Agreements. ************************************************************* INPUTS TO SEPT OIW NMSIG MEETING [Notes: (1) "e" after document number indicates that this document was transmitted electronically onto the NMSIG email exploder: nmsig@ics.uci.edu (2) "m" after document number indicates that this document is only available as hard copy and that copies will be distributed at the OIW NMSIG (3) "x" after document number indicates that this document was withdrawn and never distribued] (4) no letter after document number indicates that this document has not yet been distribted via OIW 94/192 NMSIG inputs to"Coexistence and Convergence Chernick/ Statement of Direction" Brusil 94/193e Liaison re: role of RWs in management Chernick coexistence matters 94/194e Liaison re: OIW NMSIG plans for endorsement Chernick of performance management WD pDISPs 94/199m MIL-STND OSE profiles Part 9 System DoD Management Services 94/201e Liaison re: Ensemble Guidelines comments Riegner 94/202e Liaison re: endorsement with comments on Brusil on "Guidelines for MO Profiling" 94/204e Liaison re: endorsement with comments re: Brusil Security Management WD pDISPs 94/206e Enterprise System Management Working Group Jett meeting report 94/207 Liaison to SC21WG4 re: Common Upper Layer Lebeck Management Information 94/208e Email Management group meeting report Lebeck 94/210e Distributed Systems Management sub group Broder/ June '94 Meeting Report Brusil 94/211e Working Draft of Unified Charter for System Brusil Management SIG 94/212e Meeting Report of June '94 OIW NMSIG Brusil 94/213e Solicitation for SONET/SDH MIB translation Chernick support 94/214e Solicitation for Frame Relay MIB translation Chernick 94/215e Liaison to RWs re: comments on Performance Chernick Management WD pDISPs 94/216m Ensemble Guidelines, Draft 4.1 Westgate 94/217e System Management Trends - Personal Presuhn Perspective 94/218e Connectionless Layer Network Systems Mgmt Kaminsky Ensemble and liaison 94/219e ECMA PABX MIB/Ensemble Activities Smith 94/220e Trouble Ticket Standards News Release NMForum 94/221e=Overview NMForum's TMN-related efforts Murrill 94/222e NMForum response to June '94 NMSIG report Murrill 94/223e AOW NMSIG Comments on 12059-11/12060-met AOW (AOW NM N765) 94/224m CMIP Run! Vol 3 Nm 2 IBM 94/225e Response to ISO document SC18/WG4 N 2670 Lebeck 94/22e Draft Overview of OMNIPoint Deliverables Willits 94/227e=Email Archive Service on NMF Obects Lurilli Exploder 94/228e Status Report on Security pDISPs (12059-7, Wesgate 12059-8 & 12060-6) [EWOS/EG NM/94/210] 94/229e OMNIPoint Helicopter plan review Brusil 94/230Re LAN Fault Management Ensemble Abstract INTAP 94/231e Ensemble Framework Work Item Description Folts 94/232e Kernel Functionality (Mini) Ensemble AbstractFolts 94/233e LAN Fault Mgt Ensemble Abstract Comments Shrewsbury 94/234 Connectionless Layer Network Systems Kaminsky Management Enemble (CLNSME) - Draft 6 94/235e EWOS EGNM Trip Report Kaminsky 94/236ReEWOS EGNM June 1994 Meeting Report Valet-Harper (EGNM/94/196R) 94/237e Basic AOM2x ISPs Completed Westgate 94/238e Comments on MO Profile/Ensemble Taxonomy Jonsson 94/239e Comments on OSI Lower Layer Ensemble related Jonsson documents 94/240e Draft Abstract for Telecomm Switching Mgt - Foster Customer Administration - Config Mgt Ensemble 94/241e CLNSME Working Draft 6 Kaminsky 94/242e TMN Guidebooks News Release Warner 94/243e Abstract: Telecomm Switching Mgt - Generic Foster Alarm Surveillance Ensemble 94/244e Achitecture for Using CORBA Technology in Rutt OSI Systems Management 94/245m Translation of SNMPv2 MIB Spec to CORBA-IDL JIDM (July 1994, rev of NMSIG-94/085) 94/246m Translation of GDMO/ASN.1 Spec to CORBA-IDL JIDM (July 1994, rev to NMSIG-94/086) 94/247e Enterprise Management Call for Papers(ICC'95) Fike 94/248e SPIRIT Dist Computing Platform Spec News Warner 94/249m pDISP 12059-13:Summarization [Draft 2.0] Iwamoto July 1994 (AOW NM N768) 94/250m pDISP 12060-8:AOM253x - Summarization Objects Iwamoto [Draft 2.0] July 94 (AOW NM N769) 94/251m Network Management Community Calendar Chernick 94/252e SPIRIT Dist Computing Platform for Management Firman Background/Rationale 94/253m JCG-TMN Sub-Group Report - Draft 3.0 JCG-TMN (EWOS/EG NM/94/193) SubGroup 94/254e EMA/MMC Meeting Report 8/94 Lebeck 94/255e INTEROP Sub-Agent Protocol BOF Lanspa 94/256e Distributed Systems: Operations & Management Zimmer Workshop Final Program 94/257e Journal Network and Systems Management - Malek Overview of Volume 2, Number 3 (3Q94) 94/258e Taxonomy Structure of LL MO Profiles and Mazinani Ensembles (EWOS/EG NM/94/201) 94/259 Connectionless Network Service Management Kaminsky Ensemble (CLNSME) Working Draft 7 (Paris, Aug '94 output) 94/260e Connection-Oriented Network Service Mazinani Management Ensemble (CONSME) 1st Draft (EWOS EGNM/94/202; Paris, Aug '94 output) 94/261 CLNSME Abstract (Paris, Aug '94 output) Kaminsky 94/262 CONSME Abstract (Paris, Aug '94 output) Mazinani 94/263 Data Link Managed Object Profile for HDLC Kaminsky 94/264 Network Layer Managed Object Profile for CONSKaminsky 94/265 Network Layer Managed Object Profile fr CLNSKaminsky 94/266 IS-IS Managed Objects Profile Kaminsky 94/267 IDRP Managed Objects Profile Kaminsky 94/268 TP-4 Managed Objects Profile Kaminsky 94/269 Lower Layer Managed Objects ISP Proposal Burg 94/270Re Sept NMSIG Workplan, Agenda, etc Brusil 94/271m PTN027 Status for EWOS NM Expert Group - Knight Report Number 4 (EWOS/EG NM/94/189) 94/272m PTN027 - Project Handbook Knight (EWOS/EG NM/94/189.2 and 189.3) 94/273e SNMP Testing - Potential NMSIG Activity Kutch 94/274e Ensemble Framework Overview Folts/ Ziesler 94/275m Domain Framework: a general enterprise model Ziesler/ and criteria for Ensemble Selection Folts 94/276m Basic Ensemble Folts/ Ziesler 94/277 Enterprise Network Management: LAN Status Choi/Tang Monitoring Ensemble 94/278 Token Ring Network Status Monitoring EnsembleChoi/Tang (Not Yet Available) 94/279 FDDI Network Status Monitoring Ensemble Choi/Tang (Not Yet Available) 94/280e Liaison to PT27 on Maintenance of Valet-Harper Profile Test Suites (EGNM/94/207) 94/281e PT27 Status Report Number 4 [EGNM/94/208] Knight 94/282 CLNSME and TA MO Profile Issues/review Kaminsky (EGNM/94/194) 94/283e Liaison to NMF re: RW TMN Interests Jonsson (EGNM/94/195) 94/284e Disposition of Comments on Performance Talaee EGNM/94/197) 94/285m Third Draft of Metric Objects Profile Talaee (EGNM/94/198-9) 94/286 Performance Management ISP Planning DiscussionChernick 94/287 Discussions on JIDM Participation Chernick 94/288 Guidelines Scope & Content of Ensembles Westgate (EGNM/94/203) 94/289e Disposition of Comments on Ensemble Guide Westgate (EGNM/94/205) 94/290e Managed Objects Profiling Guidelines Jonsson (EGNM/94/204) 94/291e Disposition of comments on MO Profile Guide Jonsson (EGNM/94/206) 94/292e PBX MIB Discussions Smith 94/293e New Net Management email discussion group McElearney 94/294e LL Ensembles Interim Meeting Report (Paris) Mazinani 94/295e June'94 OIW Seurity SIG Minutes Reiss 94/296m pDISP 12060-7 Metric Objects (EGNM/94/199) Talaee 94/297e Availability of Draft Ensemble Framework Folts 94/298e DSM Sept'94 Meeting Agenda Hungate 94/299 SPIRIT Discussions Murrill 94/300 ATM MIB Discussions NMF-BB 94/301 Sept'94 NMSIG Document List Brusil 94/302e Guidelines for Management Taxonomy (Draft 2) Hayashi (AOW NM N784) 94/303e SPIRIT Background Information NMF 94/304e MO Profile/Ensemble Taxonomy Comments Jonsson [EWOS/EG NM/94/212] 94/305e Comments on OSI Lower Layer Ensembles Jonsson related documents [EWO/EG NM/94/211] 94/306e ISO/IEC JTC1/SGFS Net Management pDISP EGNM review announcemnet [EWOS/EG NM/94/200] 94/307m AOW NMSIG List of Standing Documents AOW (AOW NM SD00(12)) 94/308m AOW NMSIG List of Co-Chair, Rapporteur, AOW Editors, etc. (AOW NM SD05(12)) 94/309m AOW NMSIG Attendence List of Mtg. 5-8 Sept. AOW (AOW NM SD04(12)) 94/310m AOW NMSIG Workplan (AOW NM SD03(12)) AOW 94/311m AOW NMSIG Schedule of Meetings AOW (AOW NM SD02(12)) 94/312m AOW NMSIG List of Documents for 12th Mtg. AOW (AOW NM SD11(12)) 94/313m AOW NMSIG Endorsement of Perf. Mgmt. AOW Profiles (AOW NM N883) 94/314m AOW NMSIG Comments on WD of pDISP 12060-7 AOW (Dft. 3.0) (AOW NM N885) 94/315m AOW NMSIG Comments on WD of pDISP 12059-13 AOW (Dft. 2.0) (AOW NM N886) 94/316m AOW NMSIG Comments on WD of pDISP 12060-8 AOW (Dft. 2.0) (AOW NM N887) 94/317m AOW NMSIG Comments on WD of pDISP 12060-6 AOW (Dft. 4.0) (AOW NM N888) 94/318m AOW NMSIG Comments on Guidelines for MO AOW Profiling (EWOS/NM/94/204) (AOW NM N890R) 94/319m AOW NMSIG Disposition of Cmmts. on Summ. AOW Object Profile (AOW NM N891) 94/320m AOW NMSIG Comments on WD 6 of DISP 11188-3 AOW (AOW NM N894) 94/321m AOW NMSIG Comments on Test Suite Structure AOW + Test Purposes of CMIP (AOW NM N897) 94/322m AOW NMSIG Comments on CMIP Test Mgmt. AOW Protocol Spec. (AOW NM N898) 94/323m AOW NMSIG Comments on ATS TTCN MP Module AOW (AOW NM N899R2) 94/324m AOW NMSIG Position on Taxonomy Guideines AOW (AOW NM N902R) 94/325m AOW NMSIG Position on Activities of Mgmt. AOW Coexistance + DSM (AOW NM N903R) 94/326m AOW NMSIG Endorsement of Scope and Contents AOW of Ensembles (AOW NM N904R) 94/327m AOW NMSIG Comments on Connectionless Layer AOW Systems Mgmt. Ensembles (AOW NM N905R) 94/328m AOW NMSIG Liaison Stmt. to AOW LAN-SIG AOW and WAN-SIG (AOW NM N906R) 94/329m AOW NMSIG Position on NM Forum's TMN-related AOW Activities (AOW NM N907) 94/330m AOW NMSIG Comments on WD of pDISP12059-11 AOW (DFT3.0) (AOW NM N884) 94/331mReport on SC21 Activities with emphasis on Rayner 94/332e IETF Net Mgt Directorate, Policies & IETF-NM-AD MIB/WG Status 94/333e Management/Ensemble Domain standards Artur 94/334m Advice on ICS Proforma Redman 94/335m Framework for Ensemble Specification for Folts/ Network Management Zeisler 94/336m Meeting Report of Sept'94 AOW NMSIG AOW 94/338m JIDM Comments Sayers 94/340m T1M1 Ballot on OAM&P Baseline Security ANSI Requirement for TMN 94/341m Enterprise E-mail Management: E-mail System Zhang/ Monitoring Ensemble Tang 94/342m Framework for Enterprise E-mail Management Tang/ Zhang/ Choi 94/343m Framework for Entrprise Network Management Tang etal 94/344m Enterprise E-mail Management: Message Choi/ Tracking/Tracing Ensemble Tang 94/345m Status of UMKC's work on enterprise mgmt Tang 94/346m Standardization Initiatives in Network and Kirk/ Systems Management X/Open 94/347m OSF and Management Standards Shaw 94/348m Mead DataDistributed System Mgt Experiences Hobday 94/349m SPIRIT Handout anMeurs 94/350 System Management SIG Charter Brusil 94/361 Comments on CNSME (raft of 20 June 94) AOW (AOW NM N866) 94/363 pDISP 12059-13:Summarization [Draft3.0] Iwamoto 8 September 1994 (AOW NM N892) - replaces OIW NMSIG-94/249 94/364 pDISP 12060-8:AOM253x - Summarization Objects Iwamoto [Draft 3.0] 8 September 94 (AOW NM N893) - replaces OIW NMSIG-94/250 Conformance (EWOS/TA/94/317) ************************************************************* OUTPUT DOCUMNTS FROM SEPT '94 OIW NMSIG 94/337e Liaison to RWs re: OIW Comments on EWOS Kaminsky Comments (NMSIG-94/305) on Lower Layer Ensembles Related Documents 94/339e Liaison to JIDM re:OIW reviewing activities Chernick 94/350e System and Network Management SIG Charter NMSIG (Rev 3) 94/351e Liaison: request for GDMO copy right waiver NMSIG 94/352e Liison to SC21WG4 re: naming of liaison NMSIG officer from OIW NMSIG 94/353e Liaison t PT27 endorsing final outputs NMSIG 94/354e Liaison to RWs re: availability of CLNSME NMSIG (rev 8) for comment 94/355e Liaison to RWs responding to AOW NM N866 NMSIG 94/356e Liaison to RWs responding to AOW NM 905R NMSIG (NMSIG-94/327) 94/357e Liaison to RWs re: taxonomy for lower layer NMSIG ensemble and MO profiles 94/358 Liaison to RWs re: availability of lower NMSIG layer MO Profiles for comment 94/359e Liaison to RWs commenting on Management NMSIG Taxonomy Guidelines (AOW NM N784 [NMSIG-94/302]) 94/360 Liaison to ANSI T1M1 r: TMN security NMSIG requirements and relevance of RW security-related ISPs and OIW agreements 94/362e Meeting Report Sept'94 OIW NMSIG Brusil 94/367e Liaison to RWs endorsing Perf Mgt profiles Chernick 94/369e Distributed Systems Mgt Working Group Hungate Sept 94 Meeting Notes 94/374 Laison to RWs, NMF conveying NMSIG-94/350 NMSIG