Network Working Group Susan Hares Request for Comments: DRAFT NSFNET/MERIT Version: 1 June 1992 IDRP Family Document Tree Status of this memo This memo lists the documents which specify adaptation of the ISO Inter-Domain Routing Protocol ([1]) that enables it to be used as an Inter-Autonomous System routing protocol in the TCP/IP Internet. IDRP with this adaptation will be called "IDRP for IP" in this document. In addition, this document list the versions of the ISO documents which are referenced by the Internet documents. This document gives the current status of each document. As the documentation relating to IDRP changes status, this document will be revised. During the early process of the IDRP documents, this document may change several times as the status of the documents change. Dual IDRP, that is, a single IDRP that simultaneously support Inter-Domain/Inter-Autonomous System routing in the TCP/IP and OSI Internets is currently not being specified in the Internet. When Dual IDRP is specified, this document will be revised to list the set of Dual IDRP documents. This document is an Internet Draft. Internet Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), its Areas, and its Working Groups. Note that other groups may also distribute working documents as Internet Drafts. Internet Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months. Internet Drafts may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any time. It is not appropriate to use Internet Drafts as reference material or to cite them other than as a "working draft" or "work in progress." 1. Acknowledgements (Remember reviewers will be rewarded in print!!) 2. Overview IDRP ([1]) is defined as the protocol for exchange of Inter-Domain routing information between routers to support forwarding of ISO 8473 (Connectionless Network Layer Protocol (CLNP))[2] PDUs. This document lists: - the IETF documents which define the adaptation of the IDRP protocol definition that enables it to be used as protocol for the exchange of inter-autonomous system information among routers to support the forwarding of IP packets across multiple autonomous systems. (The adaptation is defined is such a way that a Dual IDRP will be able to fully interoperate with IDRP for IP.) - the ISO documents which define IDRP and it's interactions with other ISO protocols 3. Assumptions in the IDRP for IP world The IDRP for IP protocol assumes that network addresses are globally unique. The IDRP for IP protocol cannot be guaranteed to work in an environment where network addresses are not globally unique. 4. IETF documents 4.1) Overview of Document Status Document Version Status Document Comments Next out due step ---- -------------------------------------------------------------------- IDRP Family Document 1 Pre-Draft 7/20 7/23 Internet Draft IDRP for IP 3 Internet 7/20 8/15 Version 4 Internet Draft IDRP MIB 1 Pre-Draft 7/20 7/23 Internet Draft IDRP-OSPF Interactions 1 Pre-Draft 8/3 8/10 Internet Draft IDRP-EGP Interactions 1 Pre-Draft 7/23 8/3 Internet Draft IDRP-BGP Interactions 1 Pre-Draft 7/23 8/10 Internet Draft IDRP-IS-IS Interactions 1 Pre-Draft 7/23 8/5 Internet Draft IDRP for IP Usage 1 Pre-Draft 8/10 8/15 Internet Draft 4.2) IDRP Document Family Author: Susan Hares Description: This document lists the both the IETF and the ISO standards documents associated with IDRP use in the Internet. The 7 documents listed in section 4.1 will be listed in this document, plus appropriate ISO IDRP documents. For each documents the following things will be listed: author, status, version, reviewing body, email address to send comments to, when comment period ends, action at end of the comment period, and what types of comments are requested. Document Track: FYI track Status: Pre-Internet Draft Version: 1 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document Released: 7/20/92 Comment period ends: 7/23/92 Action on 7/23/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/family.txt Comments Requested on: 1.) Format of document 2.) correctness of information 4.3) IDRP for IP Document Author: Susan Hares Description: The IDRP for IP document contains the appropriate adaptations of IDRP protocol definition that enables it to be used as a protocol for exchange of ``inter-autonomous system information'' among routers to support forwarding of IP packets across multiple autonomous systems. Status: Internet Draft version: 3 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments:idrp-ip@merit.edu Comment period ends: 8/15/92 Action on 8/15/92: version 4 created and sent to Internet Draft Location of document: internet draft archive machines: nis.nsf.net: file: internet-draft-hares-idrp-03.txt Comments Requested on: Technical Review on whole document especially on sections: 1.) Section 5.2.2 - NLRI information encoding in IDRP 2.) Section 5.2.3 - TOS->IDRP Distinguishing Attributes 3.) Section 5.2.4 - Forwarding of IP packets 4.) Section 5.2.5 - Advertising NLRI information for IP addresses 5.) Section 6 - Determining the fowarding address (Next Hop) 6.) Section 7 - RDIs used for both IP and OSI Editoral Review: Please send editorial comments on any section of the document. Please send comments to the mailing list. 4.4) IDRP MIB document Author: Susan Hares General Description: Definitions are done in two parts; IDRP General MIB, and IDRP for IP MIB. An appendix is planned; IDRP For IP GDMO. Status: Pre-Internet Draft Version: 1 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document Released: 7/23/92 Comment period ends: 7/23/92 Action on 7/23/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/idrp.mib Comments Requested on: Technical Review of the MIB variables included: 1.) Are more variables needed? 2.) Can any of these variables be deleted? 3.) ISO does not have the same restrictions that SNMP has on the representation of tables. Are the ISO variables from section 12 of the ISO document represented correctly: Section on idrpConfig: - internalBIs - intraIS - externalBISNeighbor - internalSystems - localSNPA Section on adjacentBISPkg: - bisPeerSNPAs 4.) The rdcConfig variable which is an attribute of the idrpConfig variable in the ISO document. This variable is a Sequence of tuples: (confederation set id and a SET of RDIs). How can this type of variable be done in SNMP? Is it possible? Editorial Review: Please send in any comments on the text or text format. The document tries to follow the BGP-3 MIB. 1.) Format of document 2.) MIB formats 4.5) IDRP - OSPF Interactions (standards track) Description: This document will specify the interactions between IDRP and OSPF. this document will be based on a combination of BGP-OSPF interactions document and IDRP - ISIS interaction document. Status: Internet Draft Author: Susan Hares Version: 1 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document released: 8/3/92 Comment period ends: 8/10/92 Action on 8/10/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/idrp-for-ip.ospf Technical Comments Requested on: (this section of the document will be filled in after document has been written, and initially review by the chair.) Editorial Review: (to be filled in later) 4.6) IDRP-EGP Interactions (standards track) Author: Susan Hares Description: This document will specify the interactions between IDRP and EGP-2. Status: Pre-Internet Draft Version: 1 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document released: 7/23/92 Comment period ends: 8/3/92 Action on 8/3/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/idrp.egp Comments Requested on: Technical areas of interested: (This section will be filled in after the document has been written.) Editorial review: (This section will be filled in after the document has been written.) 4.7) IDRP-BGP Interactions (standards track) Author: Susan Hares Description: This document will specify the interactions between: IDRP and BGP-3, and IDRP and BGP-4. Version: 1 Status: Pre-Internet Draft Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document released: 7/23/92 Comment period ends: 8/3/92 Action on 8/3/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/idrp.bgp Comments Requested on: Technical Review: (This section of the document will be filled in once the IDRP BGP interactions document has been written.) 4.8) IDRP-ISIS Interactions Document (standards track) Author: Susan Hares Description: This document will specify the interactions between: IDRP and Dual IS-IS. It will refer to the ANSI work on IDRP to IS-IS interactions Status: Pre-Internet Draft Version: 1 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document Due out: 7/23/92 Comment period ends: 8/5/92 Action on 8/5/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/idrp.mib Comments Requested on: Technical Review: (to be filled in later) 4.9) IDRP for IP Usage document (standards track) Author: Susan Hares Description: Most of the IDRP for IP Usage will reference the CIDR (Supernetting document) Internet Draft. The IDRP for IP Usage document will contain a sample policy configuration language, and examples on how to use the IDRP for IP protocol within the Internet today. This document will specify the interactions between: IDRP and Dual IS-IS. It will refer to the ANSI work on IDRP to IS-IS interactions Status: Pre-Internet Draft Version: 1 Reviewing body: IDRP for IP working group Email address for comments: idrp-ip@merit.edu Document Released: 8/15/92 Comment period ends: 9/1/92 Action on 7/23/92: Submitted for Internet-Draft Location of document: /pub/iso/idrp/idrp.usage 5.) ISO Documents The following ISO documents are referenced: 1.) ISO IDRP protocol 2.) IS-IS protocol 3.) CLNP protocol 4.) ES-IS protocol 5.1) IDRP protocol specification ISO Editor: Charlie Kunzinger - IBM email address: kunzinge@ralvmg.iinus1.ibm.com ISO document identifier: ISO/IEC DIS 10747 ISO SC6 document id: N7196 ISO Description: Information Processing Systems - Telecommunications and Information Exchange between Systems - Protocol for Exchange of Inter-domain Routeing Information among Intermediate Systems to Support Forwarding of ISO 8473 PDUs, 1992. Status: Editors comments from July ISO meeting will be edited into the document to form a DIS ballot text. DIS ballot text will probably be out by sometime in September. Current Document Internet Location: ftp machine: merit.edu location: /pub/iso/idrp.ps.Z Note on document print: IDRP document may require a lot of memory in your postscript printer. If you have trouble, find more memory and try again. 5.2) IS-IS Protocol ISO Editor: Dave Oran - DEC email address: (will be filled in later) ISO document identifier: ISO/IEC IS 10589 ISO SC6 document id:ISO 10589 ISO Description: Information Processing Systems - Telecommunications and Information Exchange between systems - Intermediate System to Intermediate System Intra-Domain routeing information exchange protocol for use in conjunction with the Protocol for providing the Connectionless-mode Network Service (ISO 8473), 1992. Status: Technical review and bug fixes from July ISO meeting will be edited into the document. Current Document Internet Location: ftp machine: merit.edu location: /pub/iso/iso10589.ps.Z 5.3) CLNP ISO Editor: ??? email address: (will be filled in later) ISO document identifier: ISO/IEC 8473 PDAM document: ?? filled in later ISO Description: Information Processing Systems - Data Communications - Protocol for Providing the Connectionless-mode Network Service, 1988. Status: ISO IS coming up for 5 year review with SC6 having PDAM against it for echo function (ping) and other changes. Current Document Internet Location: (none at this time) 5.4) ES-IS ISO Editor: ??? email address: (will be filled in later) ISO document identifier: ISO/IEC IS 9542 PDAM document: ?? filled in later ISO Description: Information Processing Systems - Telecommunications and information exchange between systems - End system to Intermediate system routeing exchange protocol for use in conjunction with the Protocol for providing the connectionless-mode network service (ISO 8473) Status: ISO IS comes up for 5 year review soon. The PDAM ballot for address administration (e.g. Reverse ARP) will be issued as a DAM ballot after incorporating ballot comments. 9542 is up for five year review soon; it was suggested that the 2nd edition should wait until after the DAM ballot on address administration becomes a full standard, at which time this amendment and all 14 outstanding defect reports will be folded into the base document. Current Document Internet Location: (none at this time) 9. References [1] ISO/IEC DIS 10747 - Information Processing Systems - Telecommunications and Information Exchange between Systems - Protocol for Exchange of Inter-domain Routeing Information among Intermediate Systems to Support Forwarding of ISO 8473 PDUs, 1992. [2] ISO 8473 - Information Processing Systems - Data Communications - Protocol for Providing the Connectionless-mode Network Service, 1988.